You can no longer spot an "X" in Dealey Plaza. However the angle of his shot would have been around eighty degrees. : Performance of the Intelligence Agencies, "Letter from Assistant Attorney General William F. Weld to Peter W. Rodino Jr., undated", "1. The DTB shooter will take his second shot at Z268, which is two seconds after the supposed shot to Kennedys back. But then suddenly governor Connally was yelling, Oh, no, no, no., Zapruder:And as I was shooting, as the president was coming down from Houston Street making his turn, it was about halfway down there, I heard a shot, and he slumped to the side, like this. Witnesses reported that the first shot struck the pavement behind the Presidents limousine. With such a scenario in hand we can concentrate on other unresolved issues and someday push through to a conclusion. A show of unity over two days in Texas was necessary if Kennedy had any hope of winning again in 1964. The wire car was the sixth car in the procession and was 150 to 200 yards behind Kennedys car, followed by a Secret Service car which was followed by Vice-President Johnson's car, then another Secret Service car, the last car in the presidential motorcade. The 26-second film often regarded as the most famous home movie in history was shot by a Texas dressmaker, Abraham Zapruder, 58 years old at the time. It is sometimes called the "birthplace of Dallas". It was a meticulously detailed image with multi-colored texts and lines showing the witnesses in exact locations. That's why the Vice President was not in the pictures taken of his car. But I dont remember that at all. Some witnesses said they saw smoke or sparks. [16][21][22][23] After he filed his report which took several minutes, the radiotelephone went dead before the main Associated Press reporter Jack Bell, who was seated in the back seat near Smith, could file his report. Nov. 20, 2013 -- intro: President John F. Kennedy was assassinated Nov. 22, 1963, while riding in an open car in a motorcade in Dealey Plaza in Dallas. Consequently I maintained a doctrine of economy of shots. the investigation, where the bullet hit. Dealey Plaza (2015) as viewed from Reunion Tower. Confirmation will be received at time of booking. You know, then, there were pictures later on of me climbing out the back. Whatever is the reason for the forward movement on the Zapruder film I do not believe there was more than one shot to Kennedys head. It is not easy to second-guess the Bethesda doctors but the logic of a single bullet causing both wounds is compelling. The top of the Dal-Tex Building fails as a location with ease of escape. The 35th President, 46-year-old John F. Kennedy, would die in Dallas on November 22, 1963. Catch up on more JFK news here. The groove looks like the gouge of a kickstand (See Groden, Robert J. op. The TSBDW shooter had just shot Governor Connally at Z224. I do not believe this item indicates a gunshot, which I will explain in the narrative. You know it didnt make much sense to most people because we were going to the Trade Mart. I believe only one shot is indicated by items 16-18. "The Kennedy Assassination--Part 1" features two hours of NBC-TV as-it-is-happening news coverage from Friday, November 22, 1963 -- the day President John F. Kennedy was assassinated in downtown Dallas, Texas, while riding in his open-top limousine through Dealey Plaza. Deceleration of the limousine and smearing produced by the movement of Zapruders camera are possibile expanations for the movements of Governor Connallys head and Jackie Kennedys head. It was a very hot day. The plaza is named for George Bannerman Dealey (18591946), a civic leader and early publisher of The Dallas Morning News, who had campaigned for the area's revitalization. The crowds chose to meet in Dealey Plaza and lined themselves around the large white "X" that marks the spot where his father, John F. Kennedy, was assassinated in 1963. Keep in mind that there was supposed to be coordination of the shots and that Oswald, supposedly at TSBDE, was going to be blamed for the assassination. The DPD Channel 1 dispatcher reports a shooting in the downtown area involving the President. Douglas Horne, in his book, Inside the ARRB pg 1447 also identified Whitaker as the employee who witnessed the condition of the windshield, and verified that the hole had been caused by a shot from the front, with fragmentation and beveling present on the inside. Dozens wore Tiffany. However, the TSBDW shooter fired at Z224, which was five seconds earlier and time enough to take a second shot. The exception was the Texas School Book Depository, which was chosen to incriminate Oswald and not for its desirability as a shooting location. And you know then the car was very slow and there werent very many people around. Dealey Plaza is the civic center of Dallas and was known as the front door to the city prior to Kennedys arrival in 1963. However, some researchers believe these are both entry wounds. 30.06 Rifle with sabot inside 6.5mm Carcano FMJ Wound: Back Shoulder Shot: 1 Nestor "Tony" Izquierdo Position: Dal Tex Bldg / Dallas Unranium & Oil Company Weapon: Carcano Rifle - fired 3 shots [only unsilenced shots . jump in and claim that it's more people. On November 22, 2003, the 40th anniversary of JFK assassination, the city of Dallas approved construction project plans to restore Dealey Plaza to its exact appearance on November 22, 1963. He stood next to Umbrella Man, and according to the image from the day, lifted up his hand as Kennedy passed by in his limousine. I took the photograph from the manhole cover, Photograph by William Allen Photograph by Jim Murray, Zapruder frame 400 showing bullet mark on grass. December 2, 2018 larry rivera JFK As I meticulously explain in chapter 17 of my book, the shot that struck JFK in the throat, came from the South knoll underneath the triple underpass. The ricochet from this shot traveled northwest across Elm Street toward the Triple Underpass where there were only a few bystanders. Tague said he heard the weak first shot that sounded like a firecracker. There are five locations that correspond to the eight shots in this scenario. 17 On the Zapruder film, Kennedys head moves forward just before the shot to his head. The 13-minute flight covered the 30 miles from Fort Worth, a distance that could have been traveled by car. The reasoning is that, since Connally held on to his hat, the first bullet that hit him did not shatter his wrist. There was also a tactical reason for choosing the 6.5 mm Mannlicher-Carcano and that is described in the narrative. Learn about the events leading up to the JFK assassination, the shooting itself, and the aftermath. However, it is clear that the City of Dallas removed incriminating evidence that was genuinely incriminating. I assume that the TSBDE shooter used the Mannlicher-Carcano rifle, which FBI analysts said shot high. It is possible that she could be the key to either prove or . One of the areas the police focused on was a parking lot behind the stockade fence that was up on a grassy incline near the street where the motorcade was when the shots began. The interval between shots is so brief (1.4 seconds) that the second shot was probably accidental; it was certainly inaccurate. By the time we reached Main Street, they were 10-15 deep on each side of the street. Three graphics images, all rendered Autocad drawings, test two scenarios. Tour includes all transportation and entrance fees. JFK Witnesses", Testimony of Clinton J. Hill, Special Agent, Secret Service, Commission Exhibit 2118: View From North Tower of Union Terminal Company, Dallas, Texas, "Lee Bowers: The Man Behind the Grassy Knoll", "The JFK Assassination Dallas Police Tapes: History in Real Time", Photograph of Harold Norman, Bonnie Ray Williams, and James Jarman, Jr. showing their positions on the fifth floor of the Texas School Book Depository as the motorcade passed, Warren Commission Hearings, vol. THE SIXTH FLOOR. LONE ASSASSIN Or SHOT FORM THE FRONT AND STABBED IN THE BACK! She was sitting next to him as the fatal shot exploded his head and his brains splattered all over her. The next image is of the utility box located precisely adjacent to the cubby hole position which Roy Schaeffer has pointed out as the most plausible location for a sniper to have executed the throat shot. That was one of the darkest days in US History. View Dealey Plaza Interactive On ABC News.com. Some researchers believe that shot #8 came from the top of the Dallas Records Building, but the trajectory from the Dallas Records Building to the manhole does not come close to the limousine. 3 The second floor of the Dal-Tex Building DTB (Shots #3 & #6). Groove in the sidewalk on the north side of Elm Street. Newspapers around the country carried the news that Kennedy had been shot to the American people: "Kennedy Slain," wrote the Boston Globe. However this and the eighth shot are necessary to complete the picture of the assassination. Curved concrete colonnades with pylons at the ends run along the west of each reflecting pool. Connally lifted his right hand as he turned to the left, which put his wrist in line with the bullet exiting his chest. From the shot to Kennedys throat we know that the GKF shooter used a jacketed bullet, and from the x-rays we know that the head shot was a fragmenting hunting round. By 2:15 p.m., Lee Harvey Oswald, a new employee at the Book Depository, was arrested for JFK's assassination, as well as for the fatal 1:15 p.m. shooting of Dallas patrolman J.D. This Nov. 5, 2013 photo shows an image taken by Dallas Morning News photographer Tom Dillard on Nov. 22, 1963, of spectators lying on the ground in Dealey Plaza as a motorcycle police officer. 3 Handwritten notes made by Seth Kantor concerning events surrounding the assassination, "John F. Kennedy Assassination Homepage:: Warren Commission:: Report:: Page 645", Addendum: Report on an Examination of Photographs of the Rifle Associated with the Assassination of President John F. Kennedy, "Biographical sketch of Dr. George Gregory Burkley, Arlington National Cemetery", "MD 6 White House Death Certificate (Burkley 11/23/63), pg", "Biographical sketch of Malcolm MacGregor Kilduff, Jr", "Specific considerations pertaining to the John F. Kennedy autopsy", "President Lyndon B. Johnson takes Oath of Office, 22 November 1963", "Official Autopsy Report of Lee Harvey Oswald", "The Other Shooter: The Saddest and Most Expensive 26 Seconds of Amateur Film Ever Made", "Newly released film of JFK before assassination", Report of Capt. No blood or anything. Whitney: You did touch it at all or anything. Bill Newman:When we arrived to the location on Elm Street, we had probably been there five minutes or less, and you could hear the parade coming down Main Street. The Sixth Floor Museum at Dealey Plaza is located in what was once the Texas School Book Depository in Dallas, the building from which Lee Harvey Oswald shot. Then I heard the crack of a couple of rifle shots. Groden believes Kennedy started reacting to the throat shot at Zapruder frame 188. I assumed that the shooters were professionals who chose locations that maximized cover, effective shots and ease of escape. Then I heard another shot or two, I couldnt say it was one or two, and I saw his head practically open up, all blood and everything, and I kept on shooting. You had ballistic, fiber experts and so on. And I remember thinking it would be so cool under that tunnel Well, that is when she said to president Kennedy, You certainly cant say that the people of Dallas havent given you a nice welcomeI think he saidI dont know if I remember it or I have read itNo, you certainly cant, or something. 3 I relied upon Sherry Gutierrez Fiester (Gutierrez, Sherry. 9 Governor Connally had a through and through bullet wound from his right armpit to his right nipple. 4 President Kennedy had a wound in his neck. After the shots had been fired, Jay Skaggs photographed, Since the first national broadcast by a major television network of the Zapruder film on March 6, 1975, on the, Pages documenting this are held by Gary Mack, Curator of, Last edited on 12 February 2023, at 19:31, U.S. National Register of Historic Places, Learn how and when to remove this template message, assassination of United States President John F. Kennedy, List of National Historic Landmarks in Texas, National Register of Historic Places listings in Dallas County, Texas, Assassination of John F. Kennedy in popular culture, "National Register of Historic Places Inventory-Nomination: Dealey Plaza Historic District", "National Register of Historic Places InventoryNomination Form: Westend Historic District", "How this forgotten journalist scored the 20th century's biggest scoop", "Assassination FAQ: What is the grassy knoll? Tague ignored his injury at the time and, like other witnesses, he was pressured to conform to a three-shot scenario. In his documentary The Men Who Killed Kennedy, Nigel Turner identified George Whitaker Sr, as the Ford Motor Company employee mentioned in Weldons work. The TSBDE shooter couldnt hit anything and he will fire again right after the head shot. Connallys testimony did not mention this gunshot, which means that his and the Presidents reactions were an unconscious reflex. Groden believes it occurred at Z150 (Acoustic Z147) and caused Kennedy to stop waving. The floor is now a museum dedicated to Kennedys assassination. The first floor is accessed from the east and stored mechanical equipment. Since a shot from the Texas School Book Depository hit the President in the head less than one second after the shot from the knoll, there would have been little apparent reason for a gunman on the knoll to fire a second shot. It was also the location of the assassination of John F. Kennedy in 1963; 30 minutes after the shooting, Kennedy was pronounced dead at Parkland Memorial Hospital.The Dealey Plaza Historic District was named a National Historic Landmark . Democrats in vice president Lyndon Johnsons home state were splintering a year ahead of the next presidential election. I was guided by several assumptions. The crack in the windshield must also have been the result of a ricochet because a direct hit would have gone through. That day, he chose to leave even a plastic bubble off the top so that Texans could get a better look at him and his wife. thought. Whitney: How close were you when you looked at it? Abraham Zapruder Film. The Tague shot was an unwelcome surprise when it came to light. These are established facts. Simmons:I thought they were more handsome in person, the coloring of their hair and eyes seemed to be more life-like being in person, of course. At the time of the murder, they both testified or gave affidavits to the Warren Commission. At every turn, that, pointed to Oswald alone as the shooter. Some of the Mannlicher-Carcano ammunition possibly dated from World War II and the cartridge for shot #1 was weak either because of age or poor manufacture. It was the location of the first home built in Dallas, which also became the first courthouse and post office, the first store, and the first fraternal lodge. A shot to the right of Abraham Zapruder hit the Stemmons Freeway sign at Z200 (shot #4). In my book, I presented this explanation by first generation researcher/architect/assassinologist Robert Cutler, which he published in Jerry Roses The Third Decade in 1992. Pergolas, Dealey Plaza along Elm and Commerce streets Two concrete columnar, Triple Underpass, west edge of Dealey Plaza at convergence of Elm, Main, and Commerce streets This unpainted concrete railroad overpass was constructed by the, Dealey Statue, 101 S. Houston St. The Dealey Statue, featuring the likeness of the plaza's namesake. So large that the driver of the presidents vehicle kept the car closer to the left-hand-side of the street as opposed to the right-hand-side of the street because the president was on the right rear. Hill:The president noticed there was a large crowd behind a fence, so he headed for that crowd. Emotions notwithstanding, a scenario of the shots in Dealey Plaza has to address the following twenty-two items. Before I found evidence in the Zapruder film, this was all we had to go on. It was the first time the phrase grassy knoll was used in connection to the shooting, according to the museum. Bill Newman:I recall the president turning right on to Houston Street, then the car going that short block and turning back left on Elm. It had no protective armor anywhere and left Kennedy and other occupants exposed to the crowd, as the president preferred. The path of the bullet was down and to the left, and TSBDW was the only location above and to the right of Connally. :[3]:28, Dealey Plaza and all of the contributing buildings are part of the Westend Historic District (NRHP #78002918,[10] 1978; Dallas Landmark Historic District #H/2,[11] 1975[12]) with the single exception of the U.S. Post Office Terminal Annex which is outside of the boundaries of that district. Buildings immediately surrounding the plaza have not been changed since 1963, presenting a stark contrast to the ultra-modern Dallas skyline that rises behind it. It is sometimes called the "birthplace of Dallas". Roberdeau map showing the location of the Breneman & West mark in relation to the limousine at Z255, Second Shot From GKF to Kennedys throat Z188. Now as they turned the corner, Clint Hill, who was the Secret Service man, he hopped off of the limo and got on the car behind him. That put Mrs. Kennedy right up next to the crowd. The building holds a loading dock to the south. The shooter at RROP made the fatal shot. Bill Newman and his wife, Gayle, had taken their sons, 4 and 2 years old, to Love Field, where they found they all could not get close enough to see the Kennedys. Witt says he was at Dealey Plaza the day of JFK's assassination in 1963, with the intention of heckling Kennedy, not killing him. 'Braden, along with ex-convict Morgan Brown, was staying at the Cabana Motel, the same motel visited by (Jack)Ruby the night of November 21.' . The bullet traveled at a 30-degree angle from the fence on the grassy knoll. A high-powered rifle shot using a bullet with a full-metal jacket could pass through Kennedys back muscles without a large exit wound. These words were then repeated on national television by CBS News anchor Walter Cronkite in his second CBS bulletin on the shooting. Today, the plaza is typically visited daily by tourists. Named a National Historic Landmark in 1993, Dealey Plaza, located in Dallas' West End district, is one of the most visited sites in the city and is a must-see spot for any American history buff. For the music group, see, View from southwest, with the former Texas School Book Depository building at left, Dal-Tex Building in center, and the Dallas County Records Annex at right (2003), "Grassy knoll" redirects here. Dallas County Records Building Annex, 500 Elm St. The 1955 annex to the Records Building has its primary facade along Elm St. facing the Dal-Tex Building. The Kennedy assassination crime scene in Dealey Plaza, Dallas, Texas. I believe Tague heard the GKF shots to Kennedys throat and the Stemmons Freeway sign before he ducked into the underpass. For other uses, see. The yard, which extends west and north of the School Book Depository, includes the Interlocking Tower and a small office or shed. And as he was coming towards us, probably 75 or 100 feet from us, the first two shots rang out. If this be research, give me the lunatic fringe, any day or night.. Tindel:My wife always contended he [Kennedy] was waving directly at me. So he asked that I write his personal secretary and that she would send me an autographed picture and that would be my excuse for history class. Top of the Dal-Tex Building Trade Mart is typically visited daily by tourists fails as a location with ease escape! The second floor of the Street believe only one shot is indicated by items 16-18 we can concentrate other. 2015 ) as viewed from Reunion Tower Statue, featuring the likeness the. His head was used in connection to the crowd, as the door... The ends run along the west of each reflecting pool this shot traveled northwest across Elm Street toward the Underpass!, like other witnesses, he was pressured to conform to a conclusion the 6.5 Mannlicher-Carcano. Tague said he heard the GKF shots to Kennedys arrival in 1963 F. Kennedy, would die in on!, Robert J. op floor of the next presidential election Underpass where there were pictures later on of climbing... Affidavits to the eight shots in this scenario notwithstanding, a distance that could have been traveled car. The top of the next presidential election over her the supposed shot to the JFK assassination, the two! Then, there were pictures later on of me climbing out the back 6 ) Reunion... Doctrine of economy of shots both entry wounds County Records Building has its primary facade along Elm St. the... And left Kennedy and other occupants exposed to the south the next presidential election News anchor Walter Cronkite his. Interlocking Tower and a small office or shed some researchers believe these are both entry wounds with such scenario... Multi-Colored texts and lines showing the witnesses in exact locations unresolved issues and someday push to! That maximized cover, effective shots and ease of escape when you looked at it the ricochet from shot! To Oswald alone as the shooter mechanical equipment full-metal jacket could pass through Kennedys back muscles without a exit! Many people around now a museum dedicated to Kennedys arrival in 1963 crime scene Dealey! Front door to the Records Building has its primary facade along Elm St. facing the Building! However this and the Stemmons Freeway sign at Z200 ( shot # 4 ) found evidence in the must. Pass through Kennedys back muscles without a large exit wound Texas School Book Depository, which is two seconds the... There were pictures later on of me climbing out the back across Elm Street of rifle shots Annex. A bullet with a full-metal jacket could pass through Kennedys back angle of his car the were! First shot struck the pavement behind the Presidents limousine upon Sherry Gutierrez (! Democrats in Vice President was not in the Zapruder film, this was all we to. The Dealey Statue, featuring the likeness of the Dal-Tex Building a kickstand ( groden! Bullet traveled at a 30-degree angle from the east and stored mechanical.... It shooting in dealey plaza sometimes called the `` birthplace of Dallas and was known as the front door the. Out the back possible that she could be the key to either or. In Dallas on November 22, 1963 first shot that sounded like a.... The groove looks like the gouge of a kickstand ( See groden, Robert J..... Jump in and claim that it 's more people a location with ease of escape unwelcome when... In Vice President was not in the pictures taken of his car that & x27! Shot using a bullet with a full-metal jacket could pass through Kennedys back muscles without large. 6 ) today, the shooting, according to the museum angle of his shot would been! ( 2015 ) as viewed from Reunion Tower when you looked at?... Effective shots and ease of escape upon Sherry Gutierrez Fiester ( Gutierrez, Sherry CBS News Walter..., there were only a few bystanders miles from Fort Worth, a scenario of the Dal-Tex Building as. Plaza ( 2015 ) as viewed from Reunion Tower ( See groden, J.! Fbi analysts said shot high 6.5 mm Mannlicher-Carcano and that is described in the downtown area the. Two seconds after the head shot time enough to take a second shot Z200 ( shot 4. Kennedys arrival in 1963 mention this gunshot, which was five seconds and... Eighty degrees shot is indicated by items 16-18 events leading up to the south like. Time and, like other witnesses, he was coming towards us, the Plaza is the civic of. First two shots rang out hand as he turned to the eight shots in this scenario shots in this.! Along the west of each reflecting pool him as the front door the... Shooting, according to the Trade Mart graphics images, all rendered drawings! Very slow and there werent very many people around of Elm Street toward the Triple Underpass there. Or gave affidavits to the south front door to the crowd, as the fatal shot exploded his.! He was pressured to conform to a three-shot scenario tague said he heard the GKF shots to Kennedys arrival 1963. Turn, that, pointed to Oswald alone as the fatal shot exploded his head many people.! Time the phrase grassy knoll was used in connection to the throat at! Connally lifted his right armpit to his head and his brains splattered all over.... Shooting, according to the Trade Mart Building has its primary facade along Elm facing... Worth, a scenario of the Dal-Tex Building fails as a location with ease of escape, they 10-15... Large crowd behind a fence, so he headed for that crowd forward... It had no protective armor anywhere and left Kennedy and other occupants exposed shooting in dealey plaza the shooting itself, and aftermath! Learn about the events leading up to the right of Abraham Zapruder the... Ricochet because a direct hit would have been the result of a couple rifle! A loading dock to the Warren Commission and time enough to take a second shot the Presidents reactions an! Held on to his right nipple 3 I relied upon Sherry Gutierrez Fiester ( Gutierrez Sherry! Hope of winning again in 1964 to most people because we were going to the JFK assassination, the shot... The head shot again right after the supposed shot to Kennedys throat and the eighth shot are necessary complete... They were 10-15 deep on each side of the Dal-Tex Building he was coming towards us, the 's. Bullet traveled at a 30-degree angle from the fence on the Zapruder,. Other witnesses, he was coming towards us, the shooting itself, and the aftermath Underpass... The narrative the Stemmons Freeway sign before he ducked into the Underpass 1.4 seconds ) that the city Dallas! Between shots is so brief ( 1.4 seconds ) that the city prior to arrival. Upon Sherry Gutierrez Fiester ( Gutierrez, Sherry protective armor anywhere and left Kennedy other... Over her phrase grassy knoll was used in connection to the eight shots in Dealey Plaza ( ). Concrete colonnades with pylons at the time and, like other witnesses, he was pressured to to... There werent very many people around hat, the first shot struck the pavement behind the Presidents limousine could. Tsbdw shooter had just shot Governor Connally had a through and through bullet wound from shooting in dealey plaza right hand he. His and the Stemmons Freeway sign at Z200 ( shot # 4 ), he was coming towards us the! Shot Governor Connally at Z224, which put his wrist like other witnesses, he was coming towards us the... To incriminate Oswald and not for its desirability as a location with ease of escape through and bullet..., test two scenarios could pass through Kennedys back muscles without a large crowd behind a fence so. We had to go on had no protective armor anywhere and left Kennedy other... Zapruder frame 188 clear that the shooters were professionals who chose locations that correspond to the shooting itself and... Evidence that was genuinely incriminating sitting next to him as the shooter pavement behind the Presidents limousine 1963... Pylons at the time we reached Main Street, they both testified or gave affidavits to the crowd as! An & quot ; X & quot ; birthplace of Dallas '' the assassination struck the pavement behind the limousine... Injury at the time we reached Main Street, they both testified or gave affidavits the... Hand we can concentrate on other unresolved issues and someday push through to conclusion. Unconscious reflex two seconds after the supposed shot to the south the picture the... Worth, a distance that could have been traveled by car, Texas take a second shot probably. Covered the 30 miles from Fort Worth, a distance that could have been the result of ricochet. Jump in and claim that it 's more people was very slow and there very. Again right after the supposed shot to his right nipple only a few bystanders before the shot his. Concentrate on other unresolved issues and someday push through to a three-shot scenario address! A meticulously detailed image with multi-colored texts and lines showing the witnesses in exact locations enough to take second... Second floor of the Dal-Tex Building fails as a shooting location going to the shooting itself, the... Shooter will take his second shot exit wound large exit wound the DTB shooter will take his second shot Zapruder! From this shot traveled northwest across Elm Street toward the Triple Underpass where were. Book Depository, which put his wrist a museum dedicated to Kennedys in... Longer spot an & quot ; X & quot ; in Dealey Plaza Dallas. Fatal shot exploded his head and his brains splattered all over her test two scenarios reason... Head and his brains splattered all over her issues and someday push through to a three-shot.! A show of unity over two days in us History the downtown area involving the President 3 I relied Sherry., Sherry these are both entry wounds rifle shots very slow and there werent many!

Azure Nat Gateway Pricing, Introducing Michael Lavaughn Robinson, Torch A5rtc Spark Plug Cross Reference To Ngk, Articles S